TB-3236 · REV B · Technical newsheet
Metrology & CalibrationDevice profile
Cavity 3 at 10.045 mm: Why Ticks Fail First Article Reports
A four-cavity boss reading 10.045 mm against a ±0.05 mm tolerance shows why offshore first article reports need measured values, cavity data and ISO 14253-1 decision rules — not pass ticks.
By Grace Kim4 min read900 words
Features
- Cavity 3 measured 10.045 mm on a 10.00 ±0.05 mm spec, leaving 0.005 mm margin — insufficient under ISO 14253-1 with ±0.01 mm expanded uncertainty
- AS9102 organizes FAI into three forms published by IAQG: part number, product and characteristic accountability
- AS9102 practice requires re-inspection after tool, source, material, process or method changes, or a production lapse commonly set at two years
- Cheng recommends reporting measured values by cavity with gauge identity and calibration status on every line

A molded boss specified at 10.00 ±0.05 mm can pass on all four cavities of a tool and still be unprovable: cavity 3 reads 10.045 mm, leaving 0.005 mm of margin, which an expanded measurement uncertainty of ±0.01 mm can erase. That arithmetic, laid out by Jack Cheng, principal of JCH Design & Manufacturing, is the core argument for rebuilding first article inspection (FAI) reports around measured values rather than pass marks when parts cross an ocean.
Cheng writes that a report prepared for a remote buyer must stand on its own and prove four things: the right revision was built, every requirement was checked, the numbers can be trusted, and the process behind the sample matches the one that will run volume. "A flawless report on the wrong revision proves nothing," he notes, urging buyers to verify part number, part revision and drawing revision against the purchase order before reading anything else.
What belongs in the ballooned drawing?
Every dimension, tolerance, note and specification gets a numbered balloon, and every balloon gets a line in the results table. Cheng warns that general notes and the tolerance block are "the items most easily left out" — they need balloons too.
A complete first article also covers:
- Material grade, with a certificate traceable to the lot actually used; a substituted resin can measure perfectly and still fail in the field.
- Special processes — plating, heat treatment, welding, coating — with the performer and evidence.
- Part number, date code, logo and country of origin in the locations the drawing specifies.
- Fit and function, including assembly with mating parts and functional test results.
Why borrow AS9102's three forms?
Most consumer and industrial parts carry no formal AS9102 or PPAP requirement, and Cheng says paying for a full package "rarely makes sense." The aerospace standard's structure, published by IAQG, is still worth copying:
- Form 1, Part Number Accountability: which part, which revision, full or partial first article.
- Form 2, Product Accountability: raw materials, special processes, functional tests, with certificates.
- Form 3, Characteristic Accountability: each ballooned characteristic, its requirement and measured result.
A three-tab spreadsheet can do this for a plastic housing, he writes. Where the buyer's concern extends to the process, automotive PPAP adds capability studies and a control plan; its dimensional results element is effectively a first article. Cheng's advice: specify the level and element list — "'Send a PPAP' without a level or an element list invites an argument later."
How does ISO 14253-1 change the pass/fail call?
The cavity-3 example carries three consequences, none visible in a tick column. First, provability: under ISO 14253-1 decision rules, conformance is proven only when the result falls inside the tolerance reduced by the expanded uncertainty — here, no higher than 10.04 mm, so 10.045 mm fails that test. Second, drift: an external feature formed by the cavity grows with abrasive steel wear, and a glass-filled resin accelerates it. Third, the 0.045 mm spread between cavities is toolmaker information an averaged result would hide.
Cheng's rule: demand the actual value on every line, reported by cavity, with the gauge used and its calibration status. A report that does not identify the cavity cannot tell you which steel to fix.
Which conditions make remote numbers trustworthy?
Cheng recommends agreeing, in writing before the first shot, on measurement conditions, sample identity and methods:
- State how long molded parts rest before measurement, and at what temperature and humidity — hygroscopic resins such as nylon change with moisture.
- Sample parts must come from production steel at production settings, with run date, machine, process sheet, and parts marked or bagged by cavity.
- Agree on the datum scheme and how flexible parts are restrained; two honest labs can disagree on fixturing.
- Re-measure a handful of balloons, including the tightest, on shipped parts; matching numbers justify trusting the rest.
- Where risk justifies it, use third-party inspection at the factory or a local lab — cheap against a rejected container.
What happens after a failure?
A failed first article on a new tool is normal, Cheng writes; the response is the discipline. Stop volume, fix the process rather than sorting the batch, and put any accepted deviation in writing with signatures and, if chosen, a raised drawing revision. "A verbal agreement across two companies and two languages won't survive staff turnover." An updated report should reference the original so history stays in one place.
When does a first article expire?
AS9102 practice, reflected in Boeing's supplier FAI requirements, calls for full or partial re-inspection after invalidating changes. Cheng lists them for purchase terms:
- Design or drawing change
- Change of manufacturing source or location
- Tool repair, replacement or transfer affecting the characteristic
- Change of material or material supplier
- Change to a process, inspection method or NC program
- Production lapse, commonly two years unless the customer sets another limit
Offshore programs need the middle items most: plant moves, a sub-tier plating-house change or a new resin source can happen quietly. The purchase order should require notice before the change and a new first article on affected characteristics — a partial one, if the report states why the rest were omitted.
The takeaway, in Cheng's words: a good first article report lets a stranger on another continent reach the same conclusion as the person who measured the part.
via sae.org (Original)
Filed under
- first-article-inspection-fai
- measurement-uncertainty
- iso-14253-1
- as9102
- ppap
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Instruments, test and measurement at Testbench Report.
116 articles